margarine's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[American Idle]

pretty good

But it would have been better if you'd had Gary and Simon fight to the death. And, you know, actually killed one another. Yeah. That would have been good :)

[Amerika]

wonderbra!...um...bar

That was awesome! I loved your attention to detail, and that song rules. You got a winner here

SauceHelmet responds:

Thx man, I'm all about detail in my flashes, one of the most difficult scenes was when the missile flew towards the white house, I had no idea how to animate that, it came out not half bad in the end. Thx again.

[Pongo Tester]

did you really draw this?

It looked really...REAL. No, really. I can understand why it was only short. Must have taken you AGES to get it looking that good.

i198g responds:

it took me a solid two weeks. i did it all in toon boom, i have videos of my dog like that but they were just testers, im doing one like that only with buildings and cars, 10seconds at 12fps

[A story about a Scarecrow]

goood stuff

You can't get away with doing anything weird like this anymore cos people immediately compare you to David Firth. It's predictable, and irritating. So I won't.
I thought it was well drawn, and you obviously put a lot of effort in so it gets full points for graphics and style. Your music was clean and effective, and the story was to the point.
Make more!

Mriez responds:

THANKS! Finally someone who judges the movie itself and not the genre :). I don't now why people compare it and say its ripped of or somehing.. I mean: there are hundreds of finall fantasy parodies and nobody seems to care about that. My movie isn't even based on an existing story or existing characters. So thanx for your honest judgement:).

[Creativity]

that was great...I think...

For some reason the monotony of your voice only served to draw me in more. The pictures were great, it flowed really well, and I'm quite impressed that you managed to compress it all into a file under 4mb.
Didn't think much of your teacher's acting though :P

toad2000 responds:

He wanted me to come up with a way to make him thinner.

[Element trailer]

yep

I agree with everybody else. That rocked.

[Saddest Day of My Life]

'I Am Destroyed'

Oh wow, that was the funniest thing I've watched in ages :D It was like that crappy 'The Streets' song, all cliches and cheese. Thank you

["The City"]

mmm

That was great! I really liked your character depictions, it's something I suck at. I only had TWO quibbles, and they're minor. One was the sound, I didn't think the music really fit with the whole 'loss' theme. The other was that 'foot' shot, where the guy's walking but he only has one foot :S Everything else, though, was fantastic. I loved your scenery.

[Stayin Alive]

um

I think bush actually spent more on his own inauguration than he did on Tsunami relief. In many ways, I think that reinforces your argument :)

[One Pie to Rule Them All]

nice work

The voices were impressive. You got Sam's whining spot on :) The only thing that puzzled me was the scary 'Psycho' music when Gollum produces the pie. Surely it should have been more, er, harps...maybe? I dunno. Whatever.